Copy Book Archive

‘Never Trust Experts’ Lord Salisbury seeks to calm the Viceroy of India’s nerves in the face of anti-Russian hysteria.
1877
Queen Victoria 1837-1901
Music: Alexander Borodin

© Godot13, Wikimedia Commons. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Source

About this picture …

The Tauride Palace in St Petersburg, begun in 1783. When Salisbury was Secretary of State for India, there were lively fears that the Russian Empire would use Afghanistan as a gateway to a conquest of British India. Napoleon had put Tsar Paul I up to attempting it seventy years earlier, but Alexander II’s state visit to London in 1874 had created warmer relations. (In 1894 Queen Victoria’s granddaughter Alix married Alexander’s grandson, the future Tsar Nicholas II – a rather better guarantee of peace than war.) Sadly, there are always some who gain power, win votes or even make a living by ensuring that fears are not calmed, opportunities are not taken, and wounds are not healed.

‘Never Trust Experts’
In 1877, military advisers urged Britain to ready themselves for war against the Russian Empire, citing St Petersburg’s diplomatic ties with Afghanistan, and warning that the Russians ‘could’ invade Turkey or even India. Lord Salisbury, Secretary of State for India, wrote to the Viceroy, Edward Bulwer-Lytton, urging calm.

AS to our foreign policy I hardly dare to open the subject with you. If I took your gloomy view I should commence immediate enquiries as to the most painless form of suicide.

But I think you listen too much to the soldiers. No lesson seems to be so deeply inculcated by the experience of life as that you never should trust experts. If you believe the doctors, nothing is wholesome: if you believe the theologians, nothing is innocent: if you believe the soldiers, nothing is safe. They all require to have their strong wine diluted by a very large admixture of insipid common sense.*

* As a maxim, ‘never trust experts’ does have its limitations, as the vestry of St Chad’s Church in Shrewsbury found when they invited surveyor Thomas Telford to provide an estimate for mending their leaky roof in 1788. See A False Economy.

Source

From ‘Life of Robert, Marquis of Salisbury’ Vol. II (1921).

Suggested Music

Paraphrases (arr. Borodin)

Tarantella

Alexander Borodin (1833-1887)

Performed by Marco Rapetti (piano).

Media not showing? Let me know!

How To Use This Passage

You can use this passage to help improve your command of English.

IRead it aloud, twice or more. IISummarise it in one sentence of up to 30 words. IIISummarise it in one paragraph of 40-80 words. IVMake notes on the passage, and reconstruct the original from them later on. VJot down any unfamiliar words, and make your own sentences with them later. VIMake a note of any words that surprise or impress you, and ask yourself what meaning they add to the words you would have expected to see. VIITurn any old-fashioned English into modern English. VIIITurn prose into verse, and verse into prose. IXAsk yourself what the author is trying to get you to feel or think. XHow would an artist or a photographer capture the scene? XIHow would a movie director shoot it, or a composer write incidental music for it?

For these and more ideas, see How to Use The Copy Book.

Related Posts

for ‘Never Trust Experts’

British National Character

The Fact-Lovers

American essayist Ralph Waldo Emerson saw the demand for hard evidence as a peculiarly English trait.

British National Character

The Liberty-Lovers

American essayist Ralph Waldo Emerson praises the English public for still loving freedom, despite their politicians.

Character and Conduct

The Absent Minded Conquerors

Sir John Seeley urged us to cherish our close ties to India and other nations beyond Europe.

Character and Conduct

Character and Learning

Intellectual learning is to be respected, but it should never be confused with good character.

Character and Conduct (105)
All Stories (1522)
Worksheets (14)
Word Games (5)