Fatal Counsel

CNUT also, and Edric, laid their plans for obtaining by treachery the success which they could not gain by arms, and Edric undertook to betray King Edmund. In consequence, by his advice, the king went into Wessex* to lead a very powerful army against Cnut, who, meanwhile, had laid siege to London, which he furiously assaulted both by land and water, but the citizens defended it manfully.

The fifth time, King Edmund, again fording the river Thames at Brentford, went into Kent to give battle to the Danes, but at the first encounter of the standard-bearers in the van of the armies, a terrible panic seized the Danes, and they took to flight. Edmund followed them with great slaughter as far as Aylesford,* and if he had continued the pursuit, the Danish war would have been ended that day. But the traitorous counsel of the ealdorman Edric induced him to halt. Never had more fatal counsel been given in England.*

From on‘The Chronicle of Henry of Huntingdon’ by Henry of Huntingdon (1084?-1155), translated and edited (1853) by Thomas Forester. Some small emendations have been made.

* Wessex was an ancient English kingdom that, since its heyday under King Egbert (r. 802-839), had reached right across England south of the Thames, from Kent to Cornwall. Following Edmund’s death in 1016, King Cnut granted the region to his ally Godwin, whom he created Earl of Wessex.

* Aylesford is a village on the River Medway in Kent, four miles northwest of Maidstone.

* See also If England to Itself Do Rest but True, where in the closing lines of William Shakespeare’s King John, Henry III’s cousin Philip Faulconbridge reflects that a kingdom’s greatest threat always lies in treachery at home.

Précis
One of Edmund’s most trusted counsellors, Edric, encouraged him to go on a wild goose chase so that Cnut, with whom Edric was conspiring, could besiege London once again. Edmund hurried back and drove the Danes off, but once again the perfidious Edric intervened disastrously, holding him back from pursuing his advantage.
Questions for Critics

1. What is the author aiming to achieve in writing this?

2. Note any words, devices or turns of phrase that strike you. How do they help the author communicate his ideas more effectively?

3. What impression does this passage make on you? How might you put that impression into words?

Based on The English Critic (1939) by NL Clay, drawing on The New Criticism: A Lecture Delivered at Columbia University, March 9, 1910, by J. E. Spingarn, Professor of Comparative Literature in Columbia University, USA.

Read Next

An Appeal to Philip Sober

A woman convicted of a crime she did not commit took her case to a higher power.

A True Gentleman of Verona

A young man from the Italian city on the Adige River demonstrates that class has nothing to do with wealth.

The Signing of the Great Charter

King John promised his nobles respect, but he was not a man to regard his word as his bond.