Beethoven’s First

Everyone wanted to know who Beethoven’s favourite composer was.

1824-1826

Introduction

Ludwig van Beethoven is unquestionably one of the greatest and most influential of all composers, and it was natural that visitors wanted to know whose music he admired most. Towards the end of a tragic life afflicted by deafness, loneliness and financial worries, one composer’s music brought him more solace than any other.

A QUESTION many people asked Beethoven was ‘Who is your favourite composer?’

Englishman Edward Schulz recalled hearing Beethoven say over dinner, ‘Handel is the greatest composer that ever lived’, and Johann Stumpff, a London-based instrument-maker who visited Beethoven in 1824, received the same reply. ‘To him I bow the knee,’ Beethoven added, and promptly did.

Stumpff was shocked to find Beethoven could not afford copies of Handel’s works, and silently resolved there and then to send him a complete set, if such a thing existed. It did, all forty volumes of it. Two years later it arrived from London.

‘He was more delighted with this present’ wrote Beethoven’s secretary Anton Schindler ‘than if he had received the Order of the Garter’.* Beethoven was by now in great pain from dropsy, but throughout his last days he lay on his bed rapturously turning the pages, all grief forgotten. ‘Handel is the greatest, the ablest composer that ever lived’ he exclaimed.

‘I can still learn from him.’

Based on ‘The Life of Ludwig van Beethoven’ Vol. 3 by Alexander Wheelock Thayer, and ‘Life of Beethoven’ by Anton Schindler, edited by Ignaz Moscheles.

See Order of the Garter: Royal Family Website. Beethoven repeatedly made arrangements to visit England, but ill health or lack of funds always conspired against him. One of his lasting regrets, however, was that his symphony celebrating Wellington’s Victory at Vitoria in 1813 was never acknowledged by the English court — some kind of royal award would evidently have rather pleased him.

Précis
Ludwig van Beethoven was often asked to name his favourite composer, and his answer was consistently ‘Handel’, yet he could not afford Handel’s music in full score. On discovering this, London instrument-maker Johann Stumpff sent a comprehensive edition to Beethoven, who in the few remaining months of his life derived great solace from losing himself in its pages.
Sevens

Suggest answers to this question. See if you can limit one answer to exactly seven words.

Who was Beethoven’s all-time favourite composer?

Suggestion

He called Handel the greatest of all.

Jigsaws

Express the ideas below in a single sentence, using different words as much as possible. Do not be satisfied with the first answer you think of; think of several, and choose the best.

Beethoven’s favourite living composer was Cherubini. His favourite composer of all was Handel.

Read Next

Vice and Virtue

Vice is a fact of life, wrote Pope, and God can even bring good out of it; but vice is never a virtue and in tackling vice together we make our society stronger.

A Man Called Mouse

In an enduring fable from the Kathasaritsagara, an Indian merchant explains how he acquired his nickname.

Cuthbert’s Cordon

A man steals a mother sparrow from her chick, but St Cuthbert isn’t going to let him get away with it.