Dmitry the Pretender

YET again Dmitry had defied death! The mangled corpse of two years ago was not his, but a servant’s. The Tsar lived! At any rate, devoted Marina called him husband, and many Russians were convinced.* For nearly three years Russia had two Tsars, two Parliaments and two Patriarchs. Dmitry never won Veliky [Great] Novgorod, Kazan, Smolensk or Nizhny [Lower] Novgorod, but he controlled most of the rest.

In Moscow, a council of Seven Boyars elected Sigismund’s son Vladislav in place of Tsar Vasily, before opening the gates to the Polish army. Dmitry, now surplus to requirements, was murdered in December 1610, and Sigismund claimed Moscow for himself. Sweden meanwhile seized Veliky Novgorod, and everywhere was chaos.

At last the Church stepped in. The Trinity Monastery near Moscow, following a sixteen-month siege,* circulated a call to arms; and the mayor of Nizhny Novgorod, a butcher named Kuzma Minin, answered it. He collected a few men, and by the time they had reached Moscow they were an army. There they besieged the Poles, and in 1612 drove them out amid scenes of public joy. The following year, the National Assembly elected young Michael Romanov, just sixteen but of true royal blood, to be their Tsar.

With acknowledgements to ‘A Short History of Russia’ by Lucy Cazalet, and ‘A Short History of Russia’ by Mary Platt Parmele (1843-1911). Some errors in chronology have been corrected by reference to ‘The most infamous FAKE tsars in Russian history’ by Georgy Manaev, online at ‘Russia Beyond’ (dated 2021, retrieved 2022).

* ‘Patriarch’ Ignatius, who had supported Dmitry in 1605-6, was another who spoke up for this Dmitry redux. He also established a rival Patriarchate in opposition to the canonical Patriarch, Hermogenes (in office 1606-1612). Ignatius eventually became an Eastern-rite Roman Catholic.

* The siege lasted from September 23rd, 1608, to January 12th, 1610.

Précis
Surprisingly, this Dmitry also enjoyed widespread popularity in Russia, but he never took the crown. Instead, Moscow’s nobles offered it to Sigismund’s son; Dmitry was forgotten, and murdered in 1610. Sigismund moved to take the crown himself but was foiled by the Russian Church, which roused a rebellion, and in 1613 Russia’s National Assembly gave the crown to Michael Romanov.

Read Next

A Coy and Humorous Dame

The English ‘Cato’ cautioned that sabre-rattling sanctions and other forms of coercion are never in the country’s economic interest.

Presumption and Innocence

Charles Dickens chastises those who alter the plots of classic tales to push some social agenda of their own.

The Miracle of El Alamein

Under a moonlit sky in October 1942, Allied and Axis forces met in battle on the sands of the Egyptian desert.