The Voyage of John Cabot

Some say this land was part of Cape Breton.* Others believe it was somewhere along the coast of Labrador. This they believe because Cabot is known to have said, when speaking of his discovery, “That sea is covered with fishes, which can be taken, not only with the net, but also with a basket in which a stone is put, so that the basket may plunge into the water.” And he also said that from that new country the fishermen could get all the fish they could trade. Now, it is on the coast of Labrador that the fish are most plentiful, and so men reason that he must have landed there.

We know for a certainty that he did discover the continent somewhere along the coast of what is now known as British North America. And so, from the deck of that little vessel that sailed so quietly out of Bristol harbor that bright day over four hundred years ago, our country* was first seen by the men of the Old World; and John Cabot, who was in command of that vessel, first placed the flag of England on North American soil.

* Cape Breton Island lies at the northeast tip of Nova Scotia, Canada. Several other places have been suggested, including Cape Bonavista on Newfoundland a little further northeast. Labrador, evidently favoured by Edith Marsh, is part of the mainland further north. The exact location is unknown.

* The author, Edith Louise Marsh, was Canadian.

* It would be many years before English-speaking peoples rose in the lands claimed for England by John Cabot. Colonisation attempts began in 1584 under Elizabeth I with the ill-fated Roanoke colony: see The Lost Colony of Roanoke. That was followed by the more succesful Virginia, and then by the Pilgrim Fathers at Massachusetts: see The Voyage of the ‘Mayflower’. Settlement in Canada took longer and was hotly contested by France. See also Hudson Bay and The Seven Years’ War.

Précis
Where Cabot landed is not known for certain, though historian Edith Marsh believed that his description of waters teeming with fish matched best with the coasts of Labrador. Wherever it was, it was in what is now Canada, and Cabot duly claimed it in the name of King Henry VIII of England.
Questions for Critics

1. What is the author aiming to achieve in writing this?

2. Note any words, devices or turns of phrase that strike you. How do they help the author communicate her ideas more effectively?

3. What impression does this passage make on you? How might you put that impression into words?

Based on The English Critic (1939) by NL Clay, drawing on The New Criticism: A Lecture Delivered at Columbia University, March 9, 1910, by J. E. Spingarn, Professor of Comparative Literature in Columbia University, USA.

Read Next

Hugh Hammer-King

Hugh, Bishop of Lincoln, was kind to children and animals but Kings merited firmer handling.

Diplomatic Immunity

Sir James Melville eavesdrops on Queen Elizabeth I’s music practice, and incurs Her Majesty’s displeasure.

Joseph Boruwlaski

William Burdon gives us a character sketch of his friend the ‘Count’, who did not let his small stature cramp his style or narrow his mind.