The Surrender of Vercingetorix

Vercingetorix on his splendid horse, his jewels and armour gleaming in the sunshine, rode quickly round the tribunal. Then vaulting from his horse he threw his sword and spear at Caesar’s feet, and, without a sword, seated himself upon the steps of the throne. Even the Roman soldiers were touched at the sight of this splendid hero who thus gave himself up for his country.

Caesar alone remained cold and cruel. To him Vercingetorix was merely the man who had for one day robbed him of the name unconquerable. A few minutes he gazed at him in silent hatred, then he burst forth into a torrent of wrath. In silence Vercingetorix listened. Then at a sign from Caesar he was bound and led away.

Vercingetorix was sent to Rome a prisoner. There for six long years he lay in a dark and noisome dungeon. Then he was brought forth to add glory to Caesar’s triumph.* And after having been led through the streets to be jeered at by the Roman multitude, his head was cut off at the foot of the Capitol, while upon its height Caesar knelt to the gods, giving thanks to them for his victories.*

From ‘A History of France’ (1912) by Henrietta Elizabeth Marshall (1867-1941).

* A Triumph was a magnificent street procession awarded to a Roman general who had brought glory to the City in battle. That year, 46 BC, Julius Caesar celebrated no fewer than four Triumphs, including this one for the Gallic War.

* Vercingetorix was discarded contemptuously by his arrogant captors, but to John Buchan he possessed something the Romans could not even dream of. “No Roman, not even Caesar, knew the meaning of chivalry. Of Vercingetorix we may say that he was the first, and not the least, of that succession of Celtic paladins to whom the freedom of their people has been a burning faith. He was the greatest soldier — greater than Pompey — that Caesar ever faced in the field, and no lost cause could boast a nobler or more tragical hero.” See also The Speech of King Caratacus.

Précis
Even Rome’s battle-hardened officers were moved as Vercingetorix rode in with dignity before Caesar’s seat of judgment, dismounted, and threw down his weapons. Caesar, however, poured forth an angry tirade before seeing to it that Vercingetorix was carried off to Rome in chains. There the noble Gaul was paraded as a dumb trophy, and eventually executed.
Questions for Critics

1. What is the author aiming to achieve in writing this?

2. Note any words, devices or turns of phrase that strike you. How do they help the author communicate her ideas more effectively?

3. What impression does this passage make on you? How might you put that impression into words?

Based on The English Critic (1939) by NL Clay, drawing on The New Criticism: A Lecture Delivered at Columbia University, March 9, 1910, by J. E. Spingarn, Professor of Comparative Literature in Columbia University, USA.

Read Next

Disbanding Empire

Adam Smith could not imagine it would ever happen, but he nevertheless recommended that Britain grant independence to her colonies.

Grace Darling

Mild-mannered Grace Darling persuaded her father to let her help him rescue the survivors of a shipwreck.

Mistris Park

Several English pianists impressed Joseph Haydn on his visits to London, but Maria Hester Park was a particular favourite.